Masculinity on Mute: What happens when men disappear?, By Shehab Moustafa

Growing up, I never lacked male presence — but I often felt the absence of male presence.

The men around me were hardworking, disciplined, and providers in every sense of the word. But their emotional vocabulary was sparse, their vulnerability hidden behind duty, and their tenderness reserved for rare, silent moments. As a boy, I observed this quiet distance and absorbed it without realizing it. I didn’t yet have the words to describe what was missing — only the feeling that something crucial was always just out of reach.

As I got older, I noticed how this pattern didn’t stop at the threshold of our homes. At work, in friendships, and across society, there seemed to be a collective resignation — an unspoken agreement that men could opt out of emotional accountability, that showing up meant only being physically present, not emotionally engaged.

And yet, the cost of this disappearance is everywhere — and it’s being paid, often silently, by women.

I’ve watched female colleagues carry not only their professional responsibilities but also the emotional labor of entire teams: smoothing tension, translating unspoken feelings, navigating male egos, absorbing blame. I’ve seen partners, mothers, sisters, and friends stretch themselves to fill in the gaps left by men who were physically present but emotionally unavailable — men who had never been taught how to listen, to take responsibility, to show up fully.

This isn’t to say that men don’t suffer from this silence — we do. Deeply. But we rarely acknowledge how that suffering ripples outward, and how often women are left to hold what we refuse to.

In my own journey, I’ve had to unlearn a version of masculinity that prized strength over sensitivity, stoicism over self-awareness. It wasn’t easy. It still isn’t. But somewhere along the way, I began to ask myself a different set of questions: What would it mean to be a man who doesn’t disappear? What would it look like to be fully present — not just in action, but in emotion, in accountability, in care?

The answers weren’t grand gestures. They were small, consistent acts: being curious about my partner’s inner world instead of fixing it, checking in with a friend instead of waiting for a crisis, admitting when I was wrong instead of retreating into defensiveness. These were not things I was taught to value as masculine — but they were deeply human, and deeply necessary.

What I’ve learned is this: masculinity doesn’t need to be muted. But it does need to be redefined.

We don’t need more men who disappear — we need men who are willing to stay, to engage, to feel. Men who understand that strength and vulnerability are not opposites, but partners. Men who know that being present is more than just being there.

This kind of presence doesn’t just lighten the load for the women in our lives — it transforms relationships, families, workplaces, and communities. It allows us to show up as whole people, not just roles. And in doing so, we create space for everyone — not just men — to breathe a little easier.

There’s still work to do. For me. For many of us. But I believe in a masculinity that doesn’t disappear — that leans in, listens, and stays. And I believe that redefining what it means to be a man is not just possible — it’s urgent.

Scroll to Top